The direction you liked: an elegant A circled by the orbit and its single orb. Plus the compass star, modified so it is distinctive instead of generic. The fourth card fuses both of your likes. Every mark is shown large, then at real app-icon sizes.
Orbit A
The orbit with its one orb, now circling a proper serif A. Same idea, three letterforms to choose the A.
Orbit A · compass crown
Fuses both of your likes: a Trajan-style A, crowned by the compass star, inside the tilted orbit with one orb. The most distinctive and the most "Affirmology."
icon test
Orbit A · Cinzel
A in Cinzel, the classical Roman caps your deck already uses. Calm, premium, oracle-like.
icon test
Orbit A · Playfair
A in Playfair Display, higher contrast and more modern-fashion. Sharper, a little more editorial.
icon test
Orbit A · Cormorant
A in Cormorant Garamond, the brand body serif. Softest and most literary of the three.
icon test
Compass star, made distinctive
You liked the compass but it was generic. These give it ownership: one held in an orbit, one reshaped into a single guiding star.
Compass in Orbit
The eight-point star held inside the tilted orbit with one orb. Keeps your motif, adds the cosmic system around it.
icon test
Guiding Star
The compass reshaped into a single tall north star with one companion orb. Asymmetry makes it ownable and unmistakable small.
icon test
Lockup (recommended mark)
AFFIRMOLOGY
Subconscious operating system
AFFIRMOLOGY
First-draft vectors to react to. Tell me the A letterform you like and whether to keep the compass-crown, and I will refine the curves and spacing, then export clean SVG, PNG, and a rounded app-icon, plus a richer Nano Banana rendering.